In a volatile and complex environment, no organisation can innovate alone. The question is not whether to partner — it is how to build partnerships that are strong enough to survive the inevitable tensions of working together under pressure. Most partnerships fail not because the parties lacked goodwill, but because they lacked the structures and skills to maintain cooperation when it became difficult.
Building a community of cooperation requires three levels of intervention. The first is creating a structure of interdependence — the boundaries, roles, and decision-making processes that define how people work together. The second is building a relationship of trust. The third is creating a dynamic of cohesion. All three are necessary. None of them is sufficient on its own.
Trust is often misunderstood. Robert Axelrod's research on the Prisoner's Dilemma, documented in The Evolution of Cooperation, shows that the most effective strategy for building cooperation is tit for tat: cooperate first, retaliate immediately when the other party defects, forgive as soon as they return to cooperation, and be transparent about what you are doing and why. Trust is a unilateral decision — I choose to trust you — but its maintenance depends on the other party's behaviour, and your response to that behaviour.
Two things go wrong most often. The first is failure to retaliate. When someone steps out of cooperation and you continue to cooperate anyway, you are not being forgiving — you are teaching them that the behaviour is acceptable. Immediate reciprocity is not aggression; it is the signal that cooperation has conditions. The second failure is accumulating grievances rather than forgiving. If you save up resentments and deploy them later, you destroy the conditions for cooperation just as surely as if you had never cooperated at all.
Cohesion is built through the social exchange dynamic. People stay in teams when the rewards of membership outweigh the costs. But this formula is moderated by three factors: the perceived availability of alternatives, the level of investment already made, and the level of expectations. As a leader, your job is to keep rewards high, costs low, alternatives scarce, investment growing, and expectations both high and met.
Maintaining partnerships requires three competencies: contracting, communication, and consequence management. Contracting is the ability to make clear bilateral agreements about what you are going to do together. Every contract has three levels: administrative (the what, the timeline, the measurables), professional (the how, the method, the approach), and psychodynamic (the implicit expectations that will derail the project if they are never surfaced). The third level is where most projects fail.
The CEO I worked with in semiconductors who fired people at will, never rewarded loyalty, and communicated only at the beginning and end of projects learned this lesson in the most public way possible — at a company event where sixteen thousand people refused to drum with him, and drummed enthusiastically with his successor. If you want to create a cooperative structure, you have to be extremely consistent in your contracting, communication, and consequence management. The structure either holds or it does not — and everyone in the organisation knows which.
Sari van Poelje
Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.
