Anticipation

Anticipation: Learning and scenario planning

If looping is the hardware that gathers signals, learning is the software that turns signals into meaning. Scenario planning, the four-stage learning cycle, and the fertile void — the moment between trapezes where the actual learning happens.

Sari van PoeljeSari van Poelje
8 min read
ShareLinkedInXFacebook
Scenario planning and organisational learning

If Looping is the hardware of Anticipation — the processes that gather signals from the environment — then Learning is the software: the collective intelligence that turns those signals into meaning, and meaning into action. An organisation can have excellent looping processes and still fail to anticipate, if it does not have the learning capability to make sense of what it is sensing.

Learning, in the context of the ABI model, is not individual learning. It is organisational learning — the capacity of a group to update its shared model of the world in response to new information. This is much harder than individual learning, because it requires not just new knowledge but new agreements: new shared assumptions, new shared language, new shared priorities.

Scenario planning is one of the most powerful tools for organisational learning. It was developed at Shell in the 1970s by Pierre Wack, who recognised that the future could not be predicted but could be rehearsed. The discipline of scenario planning asks teams to construct multiple plausible futures — not forecasts, but stories — and to think through the implications of each one for the organisation's strategy and structure.

The value of scenario planning is not in the scenarios themselves but in the conversations they generate. When a leadership team works through a scenario in which their core business model is disrupted by a new entrant, they are not predicting that this will happen. They are rehearsing their response — building the cognitive and relational muscle memory that will allow them to move faster if and when it does.

The four-stage learning cycle — experience, reflection, conceptualisation, experimentation — provides a useful map for how learning actually happens. Most organisations are good at experience and poor at reflection. They move from one action to the next without pausing to ask what the last action taught them. The result is that they repeat the same mistakes with increasing efficiency.

The most important stage of the learning cycle is what I call the fertile void — the moment between trapezes. It is the moment after you have let go of the old way of doing things and before you have grasped the new one. It is uncomfortable, disorienting and absolutely necessary. The organisations that learn fastest are the ones that have learned to tolerate the fertile void — to stay in the uncertainty long enough for genuine insight to emerge, rather than rushing to the nearest available certainty.

Building organisational learning capability requires three things: time, safety and diversity. Time to reflect, not just to act. Safety to say what you actually think, not what you think the room wants to hear. Diversity of perspective, so that the team's collective model of the world is richer and more accurate than any individual's model could be.

The organisations that are best at learning are not the ones with the most sophisticated processes. They are the ones with the most honest conversations. And honest conversations require leaders who are genuinely curious, genuinely humble, and genuinely willing to be changed by what they hear.

Sari van Poelje

Sari van Poelje

Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.

Found this useful?Share on LinkedInShare on X

You might also like

More in Anticipation