You have found your innovation gaps. Now comes the part that most innovators find tedious but that determines whether any of this work creates value: commercialisation. The question is not which gap is most interesting. The question is which gap you can actually build a business around.
There are three criteria. The first: can you shift your existing business to support this innovation, or would you need to start a new business to deliver it? If the answer is that you need a new business, that is not necessarily a reason to stop — but it changes the investment calculation significantly. The second criterion: which innovation gap best reduces pain, increases gain, and accelerates jobs to be done for your customer? This is your value test. The third: which innovation will give you the best return on investment?
Return on investment in innovation has three components. The first is your profit model — how you will create revenue from this innovation. The second is whether you can increase returns by working with others. The third is configuration — how you structure the product or service to maximise value across different customer segments.
On profit models: the most obvious is direct selling. But there are others worth considering. Licensing creates a steady revenue stream without the cost of scaling. Membership and subscription models create recurring revenue and deepen customer relationships. Xerox moved from selling machines to leasing them and charging per copy. That single change created an entirely new revenue stream and transformed their relationship with customers.
On configuration: McDonald's is the master of this. By understanding that their core customer was families with young children who wanted convenience, they created bundled value meals that increased profitability per transaction. Microsoft bundles its Office products so that customers encounter tools they would not have sought out independently. In my own business, accreditation as a supervisor requires completing at least one programme and ten supervisions per year — a bundle that creates a natural progression and deepens the relationship.
On partnerships for return on investment: can you create alliances that share risk and revenue? An agricultural machinery client with no marketing budget in Eastern Europe partnered with a car wax company to create a joint television advertisement — humorous, award-winning, and shared cost. Complementary partnerships, where you combine with companies that serve the same customer with different products, can dramatically reduce your cost of acquisition while expanding your offer.
Two factors that are often underweighted: time and intellectual property. The shorter the innovation cycle, the lower the cost and the faster the return. And innovations that can be easily copied or bought are not sustainable competitive advantages. Drone Grid started by building drones, then discovered that the hardware could be replicated cheaply and that regulations prevented autonomous flight in many markets. They pivoted to software — translating drone data into risk analysis for industrial installations. Intangible, hard to copy, and far more valuable. Within two years they were winning international prizes.
The final point on commercialisation: do not wait until you have a finished product to think about pricing and bundling. The businesses that involve sales, marketing, and production in the innovation process from the earliest prototype stage are the ones that launch products people actually want to buy. Innovation without commercial thinking is an expensive hobby.
Sari van Poelje
Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.
