Most innovation programmes fail not because they lack creativity but because they lack commercialisation discipline. The ideas are there. The prototypes are there. The enthusiasm is there. What is missing is the rigorous, patient, customer-centred work of turning a good idea into a viable business. The result is one of four predictable failure patterns.
The first failure pattern is Feature Shock. This is what happens when an organisation adds so many features to a product that it becomes impossible to use. Amazon's Fire Phone is the canonical example: a smartphone with so many novel features — Dynamic Perspective, Firefly, a 3D display — that customers could not understand what it was for. Feature shock is the product of a culture that confuses complexity with value, and that has lost touch with the customer's actual experience.
The second failure pattern is Minivation. This is what happens when an organisation has a genuinely innovative idea but scales it too cautiously — launching in a single market, at a premium price, with minimal marketing — and then concludes that the idea did not work when in fact the launch did not work. Minivation is the product of a culture that is risk-averse at the point of commitment, even when it is risk-tolerant at the point of ideation.
The third failure pattern is the Hidden Gem. This is what happens when an organisation has a genuinely valuable innovation that it fails to recognise as such — often because it does not fit the existing business model or the existing customer category. Kodak's digital camera is the most famous example: invented internally in 1975, suppressed for decades because it threatened the film business. Hidden gems are the product of a culture that evaluates new ideas through the lens of the existing business rather than the lens of the future customer.
The fourth failure pattern is the Undead. This is what happens when an organisation keeps investing in an innovation that is clearly not working — because too many people are committed to it, because it was the CEO's idea, because admitting failure feels worse than continuing to fail. Undead innovations consume resources, demoralise teams and prevent the organisation from investing in ideas that might actually work. They are the product of a culture that treats sunk costs as reasons to continue rather than reasons to stop.
What all four failure patterns have in common is a cultural root. Feature shock comes from a culture that values complexity over clarity. Minivation comes from a culture that values caution over commitment. Hidden gems come from a culture that values the existing business over the emerging opportunity. Undead innovations come from a culture that values face-saving over truth-telling.
Fixing commercialisation failures requires more than better processes. It requires cultural change — a shift in the shared assumptions about what success looks like, what failure means, and what the organisation is actually trying to create. This is why commercialisation is the software of Innovation in the ABI model: it is not a technique but a way of being.
The organisations that commercialise well are the ones that have learned to be ruthlessly honest about what is working and what is not — and to treat that honesty not as a threat to the people involved but as the most respectful thing you can do for the time and energy they have invested.
Sari van Poelje
Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.
