Direction

From why to what to how: the economics of purpose

Does focusing on purpose actually pay? Jim Stengel's ten-year study of fifty thousand brands, Edelman's Good Purpose Study, and the consistent finding: organisations that know why they exist outperform organisations that do not.

Sari van PoeljeSari van Poelje
6 min read
ShareLinkedInXFacebook
The economics of purpose-driven organisations

The most common objection to purpose-driven leadership is that it is soft. That it is fine for the annual report and the town hall, but that when the pressure is on, what matters is execution, not meaning. I have heard this objection from hundreds of leaders over thirty years. And the evidence consistently says they are wrong.

Jim Stengel, former Global Marketing Officer at Procter and Gamble, spent ten years studying fifty thousand brands across a hundred and fifty categories. He identified the fifty brands that had the strongest sense of purpose — what he called an 'ideal', a fundamental human value that the brand was committed to improving in people's lives. He then tracked the financial performance of those fifty brands against the S&P 500 over the same period. The purpose-driven brands outperformed the index by 400 percent.

Edelman's Good Purpose Study, which has tracked consumer attitudes across fourteen countries since 2008, consistently finds that consumers are more likely to buy from, recommend and defend brands that they believe have a genuine social purpose. In 2012, for the first time, the study found that consumers ranked purpose above quality and value as the primary driver of brand preference. That finding has held in every subsequent edition of the study.

The mechanism behind these findings is not mysterious. Organisations with a clear purpose attract and retain better people — because talented people want to work on something that matters. They make better decisions — because purpose provides a criterion for evaluating choices that goes beyond short-term financial return. They build stronger customer relationships — because customers can feel the difference between an organisation that knows why it exists and one that does not.

Simon Sinek's Golden Circle — Why, How, What — provides a useful communication frame for purpose. Most organisations communicate from the outside in: they tell you what they do, then how they do it, and occasionally why. The organisations that inspire loyalty and advocacy communicate from the inside out: they start with why, and let the what and how follow from that.

But the Golden Circle is a communication tool, not a strategy tool. Knowing your why is necessary but not sufficient. You also need to know what you are going to do about it — the specific strategic choices that translate purpose into action — and how you are going to build the capabilities and the culture to deliver on those choices. Purpose without strategy is aspiration. Strategy without purpose is execution without direction.

The economics of purpose are most visible in moments of crisis. When an organisation faces a genuinely difficult choice — between short-term profit and long-term integrity, between what is easy and what is right — purpose is what determines which way it goes. The organisations that have invested in purpose before the crisis are the ones that make the right call when it matters. The ones that have not invested in purpose are the ones that discover, too late, that they do not have a shared answer to the question: what are we actually for?

Purpose pays. Not because it is a marketing strategy, but because it is a leadership strategy — one that aligns the energy of the organisation around something worth doing, and gives every person in the organisation a reason to bring their best.

Watch: From why to what to how: the economics of purpose
Sari van Poelje

Sari van Poelje

Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.

Found this useful?Share on LinkedInShare on X

You might also like

More in Direction