Direction

Direction: Structure and the boundary mixing table

Every organisation runs two structures at once — a public one and a private one. Three paradoxes of structure, the boundary mixing table, and why leadership at this level is like being a DJ. Vertical alignment of organisational, relational and cultural structures.

Sari van PoeljeSari van Poelje
9 min read
ShareLinkedInXFacebook
Organisational structure and boundary management

Structure is the hardware of Direction. It is the organisational design that enables fast, coordinated action — the way roles, accountabilities, decision rights and information flows are arranged to serve the purpose. But structure is more complex than most leaders realise, because every organisation runs two structures at once: the public one and the private one.

The public structure is the one on the org chart. It shows who reports to whom, which teams exist, how the organisation is divided into functions or business units. The private structure is the one that actually governs how decisions get made, how information flows, who has real influence and who does not. In most organisations, the gap between the public and private structure is significant — and the gap is where most of the friction, confusion and wasted energy lives.

There are three paradoxes of structure that I encounter consistently in my work. The first is the paradox of clarity: the more clearly you define roles and accountabilities, the more you risk creating silos that prevent the cross-boundary collaboration that agility requires. The second is the paradox of hierarchy: the flatter the structure, the more informal hierarchy tends to emerge — because human groups always organise themselves around status and influence, whether or not the org chart acknowledges it. The third is the paradox of stability: the more stable the structure, the more resistant it becomes to the changes that the environment demands.

The boundary mixing table is a tool I developed to help leadership teams navigate these paradoxes. It maps the organisation's key boundaries — between functions, between levels, between the organisation and its external partners — and asks three questions about each boundary: What needs to flow across this boundary? What is currently preventing that flow? And what structural change would enable it?

The most important boundaries are usually not the ones between functions. They are the ones between levels — between the strategic level, the operational level and the front line. Information that is critical for strategic decision-making often gets filtered or delayed as it travels up the hierarchy. Decisions that need to be made quickly at the front line often get escalated to levels where the context has been lost. Fixing these vertical boundaries is usually more valuable than reorganising the horizontal ones.

I describe leadership at the structural level as being like a DJ. A DJ does not play the music — they mix it. They work with what is already there, adjusting the balance between different elements, creating transitions, reading the room and responding to what they hear. A structural leader does the same: they work with the existing capabilities and relationships of the organisation, adjusting the balance between stability and flexibility, creating the conditions for the right conversations to happen.

Vertical alignment — the coherence between organisational structure, relational structure and cultural structure — is the deepest challenge of structural leadership. Organisational structure defines the formal relationships. Relational structure defines the quality of those relationships — the trust, the honesty, the willingness to engage with difficulty. Cultural structure defines the shared assumptions that govern behaviour. All three need to be aligned for the organisation to function with genuine agility.

The organisations that get structure right are not the ones with the most sophisticated org charts. They are the ones where the public and private structures are closest to each other — where the way things are supposed to work is close to the way things actually work. Closing that gap is one of the most important and most neglected tasks of leadership.

Sari van Poelje

Sari van Poelje

Author of Mastering Agility (Routledge, 2024). Thirty years helping leadership teams build the four abilities of agile business innovation design.

Found this useful?Share on LinkedInShare on X

You might also like

More in Direction